Your next scene might seem like a terrific idea until you discover where it’s taking your novel.
Imagine that you’re playing a game of chess. You’re studying the board, looking at all the moves you could make, and you spot one that looks pretty good. So you make your move. But then your opponent moves a piece, and suddenly you realize you’ve just made a terrible mistake.
Something very similar can happen when we’re writing a novel. We can come up with a terrific idea for what happens next. But just because it’s a great idea doesn’t mean it’s the right move for your story.
You could spend the next three chapters following that idea, only to discover you’ve taken your novel in the completely wrong direction.
How can you tell whether you’re making a good move before you’ve spent days, weeks, or months writing yourself into a corner?
Every Scene Changes the Board
When you’re playing chess, you don’t get to start a brand-new game every time it’s your turn. You’ve already made moves, and so has your opponent. All these moves and countermoves have changed what’s possible on the board.
Novels work much the same way. By the time we reach our next scene, the events we’ve already written have been changing the situation. So when we’re trying to decide what happens next, we have to consider where the story stands right now.
What is the main character trying to accomplish at this point? What’s preventing them from doing that? And how is that struggle creating more pressure as the story moves forward?
The next event you choose needs to grow out of whatever’s already happening. It might make things more difficult for your character, or maybe they’ll discover something new that changes everything they thought they knew.
But something has to change that matters to the story you’re telling. Otherwise, you can end up with a scene that’s maybe interesting by itself, but it’s not really taking the story anywhere. And that’s where we can get in trouble, because that’s the kind of scene that can take us to a dead end, which is not where we want to go.
When we’re writing a story, it’s important that we’re following a path toward the climax. When we get to the next scene and want to know, Well, what happens next? it’s about coming up with something that’s going to take us further down that road and probably make it more difficult for our main character.
But maybe you understand exactly where your story is going, and you still can’t figure out what should happen next. Sometimes it’s the way you’re approaching that question that’s keeping you from finding the answer.
What Happens Next for Elara?
Let me give you an example. I created a story for a class that I taught in my Writer’s Brain Studio a while back, and I want to share it with you because it gives us an interesting way to look at this.
In this story, our main character is Elara Venn, and she is what’s called a caller. In her world, a few people have the ability to communicate with someone who’s recently died, but they only have a short time to do it before that connection fades away.
Eight years ago, Elara’s husband, Daniel, disappeared. His burned-out car was found, but his body never was. Eventually, she had to accept that he was gone.
Then one day, she’s called in to communicate with a murdered stranger. When she makes contact with him, he recognizes her.
He says, “Elara Venn, I’ve been looking for you. Daniel is alive. Find Calder. He knows.”
And then he’s gone.
Imagine you’re writing this story. Elara has just learned that the husband she’s been grieving for eight years might still be alive, and she’s got one clue: this mysterious person named Calder. She has no idea who he is.
You’re sitting there writing this story. What would need to happen next?
You might have her start investigating Calder, and that seems like a reasonable direction, right? But where would that lead? And is there another possibility that might create an even more interesting story?
Why Writers See Different Possibilities
It was really cool when I gave this situation to the writers in my studio. They came up with some very different ideas for what should happen next. And what fascinated me was how differently they approached the problem.
Why do some writers see possibilities that others are likely to completely overlook? And how can you use that to find your own way forward, either when you’re stuck or when you’re not sure you’re taking the right next step?
One of the things I’ve learned from working with writers for many years is that we can be trying to accomplish exactly the same thing, but we’re going to approach it in completely different ways.
Some writers naturally look for the logical steps that’ll get them from one point to the other. Others are drawn more toward unexpected possibilities or the emotional experiences of their characters.
That’s why I developed my seven Writer Mindset Types. I wanted to help writers understand how their own creative brains worked so they could find ways of writing that would come more naturally to them.
What It Means to Borrow a Brain
Here’s what I’ve done: I’ve taken the creative strengths of those seven Writer Mindset Types, and I’ve developed seven different ways to help you discover what should happen next in your story, or at least what might be a good option.
Each of these approaches gives you a different way to explore the story and find good possibilities for where it could go next. You can start with the approach that fits your Writer Mindset Type, once you take the quiz. But if that isn’t getting you anywhere, you can try one of the other six.
I call that borrowing a brain.
You’re looking at the same story with the same characters and patterns, but now you’re bringing a completely different creative strength to it. And you might be amazed at what you discover.
When I tried this with my group of writers, it was a lot of fun to watch what happened because we started with the same fictional story I just told you about. As we explored it through the different mindsets, people started coming up with all sorts of possibilities for what could happen next. Each one would have taken the story in a completely different direction.
It was interesting because the different directions often lined up with the types of genres the writers liked to write.
Creativity Doesn’t Have to Mean Losing Structure
For those of you who hear me talk about structure and how important it is to know the steps your story is taking, and you say, “Well, I don’t want to be formulaic,” I get that. I didn’t want that either when I first started writing.
But I’ve learned since then that it’s awfully hard to be formulaic if you’re tuning into your own creativity. I watched several different writers take the same scenario and, using these Writer Mindset Types, come up with completely different stories. Each story would have fit what that writer liked to write. They could take it in that direction, but it still had structure, and it still fit the story we were trying to tell.
That’s what’s important in creating a story readers are going to enjoy. And you can try this method with any story.
After we finished the sample story with Elara, the writers applied these different mindset steps to their own stories. One writer who had been really struggling to figure out how to bring two characters together suddenly had a breakthrough idea on how to do it simply because of this system.
That’s what’s so exciting about this approach. You have seven different ways to explore the story you’re actually writing. And when one approach isn’t helping, you can try another and see what it opens up.
Let’s put this to work with our story. I’m going to show you two of my seven Writer Mindset approaches, and we’ll start from exactly the same point in the story each time, just like we did in my studio master class. I think you’re going to be surprised by how differently they can take us forward.
Start With the Obvious Ideas
Let’s go back to Elara. She’s just learned that her husband might still be alive, and the only clue she has is this mysterious person named Calder.
If you were writing the story and got stuck here trying to figure out what happens next, what would you do?
Well, you might sit down and start brainstorming. And the thing with brainstorming, guys, is that it’s good as a starting activity. But it often isn’t good at determining the best next step for your story. When we first start brainstorming, we often come up with the most obvious ideas. Sometimes we keep circling those same surface possibilities without finding anything that excites us.
So let’s start brainstorming. Maybe Elara searches the internet for Calder. She wants to find out who he is because this murdered stranger told her Calder knows. Maybe she goes to the police. Maybe she tries to find out who the murdered man was and how he knew Daniel.
These are all reasonable ideas, and you could certainly build a story around them.
But let’s say you’ve been going around and around with ideas like these, and nothing’s really grabbing you. It doesn’t fit. You keep coming back to the same old, same old possibilities. It just seems ho-hum, and you’re having trouble finding one that you want to write.
Well, this is the perfect opportunity to do what I call borrow a brain.
Borrow the Pathbreaker’s Brain
We’re going to borrow the brain of one of my seven Writer Mindset Types: the Pathbreaker.
Pathbreakers are writers who love challenging expectations. They’re drawn to the unexpected, and they enjoy finding ways to do things differently.
We’re going to take that creative strength and put it to work on Elara’s story.
The most obvious thing that would happen next is that Elara has been told to find Calder, so naturally she’s going to start looking for him.
But with the Pathbreaker mindset, we’re going to turn that around. We’re going to turn it on its head. We’re going to do the exact opposite of what is expected because the Pathbreaker likes to break the rules.
So let’s let them.
They’re going to say, “How about this? How about if Calder finds her?”
Now think about what that does to our story.
Calder seeks her out and demands to talk to her. Suddenly, Elara has this mysterious person showing up in her life. He’s someone who may know what happened to Daniel, but he could also be someone who’s dangerous.
And that raises all kinds of possibilities.
What Changes When Calder Finds Her?
Elara’s going to be asking, “How does Calder know where to find me? Why has he come looking for me? Who is this dude? And if he’s involved in Daniel’s disappearance, what kind of trouble might he bring with him?”
We could even have Elara discover that someone’s followed Calder to her house. Now she’s in danger, and she’s going to have to decide what to do about it.
Do you see what happened there? We started with the same story and the same problem, but by approaching it the way a Pathbreaker might, we’ve discovered a direction that could lead to an entirely different next scene, and a more exciting one.
Notice how this possibility still connects to the story we’ve established. Elara still wants to find out what happened to Daniel. Calder may have the answers, but his arrival could also bring the opposing force right to her doorstep.
Suddenly, the pressure is rising, too.
We know this could be a good next thing to happen because it’s putting our main character in danger. It’s possibly connecting her to the opposing force. It’s raising the pressure. The stakes are getting higher.
You can see how this approach can help you come up with what happens next in a way that’s going to serve your story a lot better than just some ho-hum idea you come up with on the fly.
We just used the Pathbreaker’s approach to come up with a surprising turn in the plot. But would another Writer Mindset lead us in the same direction?
Let’s go back to the moment she hears that Daniel’s alive and try a completely different approach. I think you’re going to see how much the story can change.
Borrow the Heartsmith’s Brain
We’re going back to Elara right at the moment when she learns that Daniel might still be alive. We’ve already seen what can happen when we approach the story like a Pathbreaker, or when we just approach it with the same old, ho-hum brainstorming.
Now we’re going to borrow the brain of a Heartsmith.
The Heartsmith focuses on the emotions of the situation, on the feeling, on the purpose, on what drives a person emotionally.
When we’re trying to figure out what happens next, we often focus on the events of the outside story. We might brainstorm things that could happen to our characters. Elara could go research who Calder is, or maybe another murder takes place. Maybe she discovers someone’s following her, or maybe she gets a threatening phone call.
These could all be good possibilities, but they’re all in the outside world.
Heartsmiths are naturally drawn to the emotional lives of their characters. They’re interested in what people feel, what they’re struggling with inside, and how those struggles affect the decisions they make.
We can use that creative strength to find our next scene.
Let’s think about what Elara has just experienced from the Heartsmith’s point of view. What does she feel about this?
For eight years, she’s believed her husband was dead, and she’s grieved for him. She’s probably tried to put that behind her. She’s spent years of her life trying to get herself back together.
And now, suddenly, someone tells her that Daniel’s alive.
The Emotional Struggle Leads to an Action
Imagine what that would do to her. Part of her would desperately want to believe it, probably. But what if it turns out to be a lie? And what if she allows herself to hope only to lose him all over again?
That could be devastating.
Now we’ve found something that’s going to be very difficult for Elara to face. As a Heartsmith, we can use this emotional struggle to figure out what she might do next.
Instead of Calder showing up and finding her, what if Elara goes home after that encounter and, instead of immediately searching for Calder, finds herself staring at an old voicemail from Daniel on her cell phone?
It’s been years since she’s listened to it, and she’s kept the message because she can’t bear to erase it. But listening to it brings back too much pain, so she’s avoided that.
Now she has a reason to listen to it again.
If you’re approaching this from the Heartsmith’s point of view, that’s your next scene.
Maybe when she finally works up the courage to play this message, she hears Daniel mention something she didn’t remember he said before. Maybe he says something that perks up her ears because, now that she knows what she knows, it means more than it did before.
Suddenly, she has a possible lead she never realized she had.
How an Emotional Choice Moves the Plot
Think about how we got there. We started by exploring Elara’s emotional struggle, and that led us to an action she might take because of it.
That opened up a whole new possibility for the plot. We could build an entire scene around her struggling with whether she should listen to that message, what she hears when she finally does, and how that changes things.
Now we’re moving the story forward in a way that directly connects to who Elara is and what she’s going through.
Look at what we’ve discovered. We took exactly the same starting point and used two different Writer Mindsets to explore what could happen next.
The Pathbreaker led us toward an unexpected encounter with Calder that ratcheted up the danger. The Heartsmith led us toward an emotional decision that touched her heart while possibly uncovering a clue.
Either possibility could work, and each one gives us something different to build on.
But now we’ve got another problem. What if you’ve come up with several possibilities that could take your novel in different directions? How do you know which one is right?
As we saw with our chessboard, every move you make changes what happens afterward.
Think Ahead Before You Choose What Happens Next
Let’s go back to our chessboard again. Remember how we talked about the move that looked promising until your opponent made a move and suddenly you realized you were not on the winning side?
One of the things you can learn when you play chess is to think ahead about what might happen because of the move you’re considering. You’re looking at the position you’re in right now, but you’re also thinking about where that move might take you.
We can do the same thing in our novels.
Let’s look at the two possibilities we came up with for Elara. In the Pathbreaker example, Calder shows up looking for her, and that could be a great way to bring the danger right to her doorstep.
But in the Heartsmith example, Elara listens to that old voicemail from Daniel and discovers a clue she never knew she already had. After that, she has to decide if she’s willing to follow this clue, if she’s brave enough to do that, or if she even wants to open up this whole can of worms again.
If we’re looking at those two and saying, “Okay, which one should I choose?” the answer depends entirely on what your story needs at this particular moment.
What Does Your Genre Need?
Something else we need to consider is the genre we’re writing in.
If I were writing this as a mystery or thriller, I might be drawn toward the first possibility, where Calder shows up unexpectedly and ratchets up the danger.
But if I were writing this as more of a drama or women’s fiction novel, I might want to spend more time exploring Elara’s emotional struggle. That voicemail scene could be a powerful moment in a story that’s focused more on grief, hope, and relationships than on the thrill of the mystery.
Genre is a good place to start, but it’s not the only thing you want to consider. Of course, a mystery can have emotional depth, and a drama can have danger. Those aren’t exclusive.
What Has Your Story Already Done?
The next thing you want to look at is what your story’s already done.
Maybe you’ve already spent some time exploring grief, and now you want something to happen that forces Elara into action. In that case, Calder showing up might be the better choice for your story, no matter what genre it is.
Or maybe you’ve been moving through a lot of action already, and you want readers to experience what this discovery really means for her. Then the second scene might be more what your story needs.
You might even end up using both ideas. Maybe Elara listens to the voicemail first, and the clue she discovers eventually leads her to an encounter with Calder.
But think about how differently the story might unfold depending on which scene you write first.
Ask What Your Next Scene Will Change
When you’re considering an idea for your next scene, think about what it’s going to change in the story. How will it affect what your character is trying to accomplish, and what new difficulty might it create for them?
Once the scene is over, what will your character have to do because of what just happened?
In other words, what road is this going to take you down?
Because if you write a scene and nothing really changes, you may find yourself right back where you started, which is not where you want to be. Instead, you want to push the story forward.
That’s what I’m hoping you can take away from this. You can have all kinds of creative possibilities available to you about what happens next. Your Writer Mindset Type can help you discover more of them, but you also want to think about how those possibilities fit into the story you’re already telling.
If you’re sitting there with your own manuscript, trying to figure out how to put all this into practice, let’s walk through how you can give it a try.
The Next Scene In Your Story
Think about a place in your novel where you’ve been having trouble figuring out what happens next, and think about how you’ve been trying to solve that problem.
Have you been coming up with the same kinds of ideas over and over from just the surface mind? Are you having trouble seeing any other possibilities?
Remember what happened with Elara? We started with exactly the same story situation, but by borrowing different Writer Mindsets, we found two very different directions we could take it.
This week, try borrowing a brain. Take that place where you’re stuck and see what happens when you approach it through one of the two mindsets we explored today.
Remember, we’ve only explored two of them here. There are five more approaches you can use to discover possibilities for your story. Depending on where you’re stuck, a completely different mindset might be just what you need to get going again.
If you’d like the complete system to work with, the What Happens Next Toolkit gives you the full workshop, all seven creative approaches, and resources you can use with your own novel.
Featured image by cookie studio via Magnific.

